1mentions
2003first mention
2003last mention
approvedfinal signal

Summary

An applicant proposed building a second house on a lot on Ayala Avenue near Forest Street. The applicant failed to disclose a 35-foot Coast Live Oak (2-foot trunk diameter, 45-foot canopy) on the boundary, less than 5 feet from the proposed structure. After two zoning variances were approved on appeal, a tree permit was filed and ultimately approved with conditions but without significant design changes, triggering a city-wide review of Tree Protection Ordinance administration.

residentialmixedmediumapproved

Ayala Avenue near Forest Street

Aliases

Ayala Avenue second house / Tree Protection Ordinance dispute

Timeline

2003_10

Ayala Avenue second house / Tree Protection Ordinance dispute

An applicant proposed building a second house on a lot on Ayala Avenue near Forest Street. The applicant failed to disclose a 35-foot Coast Live Oak (2-foot trunk diameter, 45-foot canopy) on the boundary, less than 5 feet from the proposed structure. After two zoning variances were approved on appeal, a tree permit was filed and ultimately approved with conditions but without significant design changes, triggering a city-wide review of Tree Protection Ordinance administration.

mixedapprovedmedium

Quotes

The forthcoming review was triggered by a project proposed last year on Ayala Avenue near Forest Street. The applicant, who wanted to build a second house on her lot, failed to disclose in the project plans that there was a 35-foot high Coast Live Oak, with a trunk diameter of 2 feet and a 45-foot canopy, sitting on the boundary of the lot, less than 5 feet from the proposed structure.2003_10 - Tree Protection Ordinance article
Only time will tell whether the tree will be saved.2003_10 - Tree Protection Ordinance article conclusion